Abstract
The public display of copyrighted musical recordings in commercial hospitality establishments (hotels, cafes, & restaurants) emerges as an ever-increasing site of litigation concerning Indian copyright enforcement. The dispute is over Phonographic Performance Limited or PPL. PPL holds ownership through assignments over a large portion of India’s copyrighted sound recordings. But PPL has not been registered as a copyright society since 2014. Two decisions from the Delhi High Court have added uncertainty. One is a Single Judge order dated 03.03.2025. The other is the order of the Division Bench dated 15th April, 2025. Both cases deal with how to read Section 33 of the Copyright Act, 1957, especially for the hospitality industry. In the Single Judge view, PPL can license its catalogue even without Section 33(1) registration. The court reasoned that, because PPL is an assignee-owner under Sections 18 and 30, it has an inherent right to grant licenses for its repertoire. The Division Bench took a different position. It said that if an entity is not registered under Section 33(1), it should be treated as a third party to the copyright owners. On that basis, such an entity cannot run licensing work under the mandatory collective management system in Chapter VII. This restriction would apply even if the entity holds the copyright title. The Supreme Court, while dealing with the appeal, has paused only the part in paragraph 27 of the Division Bench order. It also said that the Single Judge's interim injunction will not be effective during this time. Because of this, the main issue about whether Section 33 applies to PPL is still not decided, and it will wait for the final round of adjudication. In the meantime, the hospitality industry is left without clear guidance on what it must do for licensing. This paper uses legal analysis and compares the situation with the United States. In the US, there is a “homestyle exception” under 17 U.S.C. §110(5). The paper says the basis for that exception is a specific statutory carve-out aimed at small commercial places. The paper argues that this does not fit well with India's licensing system. India does not have an equivalent carve-out. So, the paper says any similar exemption in India would need a clear law change made by the legislature first. The paper also says that the Division Bench's approach, focused on purpose, has made enforcement unclear. Because of that, the paper calls for a law-based licensing route that works like a single place to apply. It suggests this should be for unregistered repertoire aggregators. It also asks that a clearly named regulator run the system, with rules on tariffs, clear transparency steps, and limits meant to stop monopoly-like behaviour or anti-competitive conduct.
References

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Copyright (c) 2026 The Legalis IP Quarterly
